OK, this might seem obvious to all of you, but I do get readers asking if they can use their FF miles for official travel and then file for reimbursement based upon the GSA fare. Trading miles for money doesn’t cut it in the Government system. Not to mention that the airlines might confiscate your miles if they got wind of a scheme like this. When researching a topic for this week, I came across on old court case where someone tried this unseccessfully and I thought that I would share in case you’re interested.
Dr. Roy Roth, a civilian employee of the Department of the
Army in Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, was sent on
temporary duty to Jackson Hole, Wyoming in September 1995.
According to the Army, the cost of a round-trip Government ticket
was $1,347. Dr. Roth planned to stop for personal reasons in
Denver, Colorado. When he found that the stopover would cost him
an additional $260, Dr. Roth decided to use his personal frequent
flyer miles to obtain a round-trip ticket from Raleigh-Durham to
Denver. After telling Dr. Roth initially that reimbursement for
the value of the trip “seemed fair,” the Government travel office
informed him a few days before the trip that he could not be
reimbursed for a ticket “purchased” with frequent flyer miles.
Dr. Roth went ahead as planned and filed a claim which included a
charge of $352, which was the Government contract price for a
round-trip ticket from Raleigh-Durham to Denver, as well as a $50
fee which Dr. Roth incurred in connection with redemption of the
mileage credits. The round-trip ticket from
Denver to Jackson Hole cost the Government $446, for a total
airfare of $848 using Dr. Roth’s methodology.
The agency denied Dr. Roth’s claim for the value of the
Raleigh-Durham to Denver portion of his trip because he used
frequent flyer miles to obtain it. Dr. Roth has asked the Board
to review that denial. They later granted reimbursement for the $50 fee for using his miles.
The legal basis for this is that you can only be reimbursed for an expense you incur. If you incur nothing, and miles have zero value in a legal sense, then you cannot be reimbursed. I know that there are a lot of people out there that try to put a value on miles (generally $0.02 per mile), however, they actually have no value as they are airline funny money that could be taken away at any moment. The miles technically belong to the airlines, not you.
Hmmm, I guess if someone hacked your account and stole all of your miles, it wouldn’t be a crime because they didn’t steal anything of value? Run that past your local JAG officer and watch his or her head spin!